Lawsuits filed in Franklin County are challenging whether Ohio’s workers’ compensation appeals judges meet legal qualifications, raising questions about how the state’s system for resolving disputes is administered.
The suits argue that the three members of the Ohio Industrial Commission, which hears appeals of Bureau of Workers’ Compensation decisions, do not meet a statutory requirement for six years of recognized expertise in workers’ compensation law. Attorneys for injured workers say that could affect the legal standing of past rulings. Supporters of the commissioners maintain the officials are qualified and that the lawsuits are aimed at reversing unfavorable decisions.
For manufacturers, the case introduces new uncertainty into a system central to workplace injury claims and compliance.
“Manufacturers are paying close attention to how the courts interpret the statute and what the outcome could mean for the appeals process,” said Jacob Sargent, director of public policy services for the Ohio Manufacturers’ Association. 2/2/2026