California’s sweeping climate disclosure mandates took a significant hit last week, delivering some welcome relief to manufacturers facing costly and complicated reporting requirements.
On Nov. 9, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit found that California’s requirements for companies to report indirect emissions from suppliers and customers are likely unconstitutional. The court also raised constitutional concerns about a separate law requiring companies with more than $500 million in annual revenue to disclose climate-related financial risks. Both measures could have far-reaching implications for Ohio manufacturers doing business in California, regardless of where their facilities are located.
“California wants Ohio manufacturers to account for emissions from companies they don’t own, suppliers they don’t control and customers halfway around the world,” said James Lee, managing director of public policy services for the Ohio Manufacturers’ Association. “That’s an extraordinary demand from a state that doesn’t have to pay the compliance bill. The court was right to question how far this goes.”
The ruling leaves California’s requirements for larger companies to report direct emissions and emissions from purchased energy intact, but puts two of its more burdensome mandates in jeopardy. As Cleveland-based law firm Thompson Hine notes in its analysis, the legal fight isn’t over. Manufacturers still subject to California’s reporting rules should keep a close eye on what happens next. 11/17/2026